Toilet Keeps Running? How to Stop It Step by Step

A toilet that keeps running is either leaking water from the tank into the bowl, usually past a worn or stuck flapper, or overfilling into the overflow tube because the fill valve doesn't shut off. Lift the tank lid to see which it is.

If water is spilling into the overflow tube, lower the water level or clean the fill valve; if not, do a food-colouring test and replace the flapper if colour reaches the bowl. Both are usually simple, inexpensive fixes.

By , maker of TalkFixAI · Published

Inside an open toilet tank showing the fill valve, float, overflow tube, flush chain and rubber flapper

Watch the tank, then fix what you see

  1. Step 1: Lift the lid and watch

    Take off the tank lid and watch while the toilet runs. If water is flowing over the top of the open overflow tube in the middle of the tank, the water level is too high or the fill valve isn't closing. If the level stays below the overflow but the toilet keeps refilling now and then, water is leaking into the bowl, usually past the flapper.

  2. Step 2: Check the flush chain

    A chain that is too tight holds the flapper slightly open; one that is too long can get caught under it. Kohler suggests roughly one to two links of slack. Adjust the clip on the flush lever arm and check the flapper drops flat onto its seat after a flush.

  3. Step 3: Lower the water level

    The water should stop below the top of the overflow tube; many tanks have a water-line mark. Kohler advises adjusting the level so it doesn't overfill into the overflow. Depending on the fill valve, turn its adjustment screw or slide its float clip down, or on an older ball float, gently bend the arm so the ball sits lower. Flush and check where the water stops.

  4. Step 4: Flush debris out of the fill valve

    If the fill valve keeps hissing or the water keeps rising, grit may be stuck in its cap. Kohler notes that sediment or debris lodged in the fill valve cap is a common cause. Turn off the water supply, remove the cap as the fill valve's instructions show, and briefly turn the water on (with a cup over the valve) to flush it. Refit the cap. If it still runs, replace the fill valve.

  5. Step 5: Do the food-colouring test

    To find a silent leak, US EPA WaterSense suggests putting a few drops of food colouring or a dye tablet in the tank and waiting 10 minutes without flushing. If colour appears in the bowl, water is leaking past the flapper. Flush afterwards so the dye doesn't stain the tank.

  6. Step 6: Replace the flapper or seal

    Turn off the water and flush to empty the tank. Unhook the old flapper and take it to the shop to match it, or note your toilet's brand and model. Fit the new one, set the chain slack, turn the water back on and test again. EPA WaterSense recommends replacing flappers at least once every five years, and Fluidmaster warns that in-tank cleaning tablets containing bleach or chlorine can damage them.

Why a toilet keeps running

After each flush, the flapper (or seal) drops back onto the flush valve to close the bottom of the tank, and the fill valve refills the tank until its float rises and shuts the water off. A toilet runs when one of those doesn't close: the flapper leaks or is held open by the chain, or the fill valve keeps letting water in so it spills down the overflow tube. Either way, water flows into the bowl and down the drain.

A leaking toilet can waste a lot of water without you noticing, which is why EPA WaterSense suggests checking for silent leaks at least once a year.

Flapper toilets and dual-flush cisterns

Many toilets in the US have a rubber flapper on a chain. Many newer toilets, including dual-flush cisterns with push buttons that are common in India, use a canister-style flush valve with a rubber seal instead of a flapper. The same tests apply, but the seal and its parts are specific to the model, so find the brand and model (often printed inside the tank) before buying parts.

Ghost flushing

If the toilet refills briefly on its own every so often without anyone using it, that is usually a slow flapper or seal leak. Fluidmaster notes that the dye test can miss very slow leaks: turn off the supply, mark the water level, and check later. If it has dropped, water is escaping into the bowl.

Parts and tools you may need

Most fixes in this guide need no parts, so do the checks first. If you do need one, match it to your brand and model before you buy.

As an Amazon Associate, AICK Studio earns from qualifying purchases. It does not change the price you pay.

When a running toilet needs a plumber

Call a plumber if:

  • the shut-off valve behind the toilet won't turn, leaks or is missing,
  • water leaks onto the floor around the tank bolts or the base of the toilet,
  • the tank or bowl is cracked,
  • a new flapper or fill valve doesn't stop the running,
  • you can't find matching parts for a concealed or wall-hung cistern.

Do not over-tighten the tank bolts: porcelain cracks easily.

Ghost flushing and other toilet questions

Why does my toilet keep running?

Either water is leaking from the tank into the bowl, usually past a worn or stuck flapper or seal, or the fill valve isn’t shutting off so water spills into the overflow tube. Lifting the tank lid and watching tells you which.

How do I test my toilet for a leak?

US EPA WaterSense suggests adding a few drops of food colouring or a dye tablet to the tank, waiting 10 minutes without flushing, and checking the bowl. If colour shows up, the flapper is probably leaking. Flush afterwards so the tank doesn’t stain.

How often should a toilet flapper be replaced?

EPA WaterSense recommends replacing flappers at least once every five years to keep a good seal. Replace it sooner if it is warped, cracked or slimy, or if the dye test shows a leak.

Why does my toilet refill on its own?

A toilet that refills on its own is often called ghost flushing. Ghost flushing usually means water is slowly leaking from the tank into the bowl, most often past the flapper or seal, so the fill valve tops the tank up again.

Can toilet tank cleaning tablets cause a running toilet?

Yes, in-tank cleaning tablets can. Fluidmaster warns that in-tank tablets containing bleach or chlorine can damage the flapper and make it leak. Use a cleaner that is safe for tank parts, or clean the bowl instead.

Checked against: US EPA WaterSense: Home maintenance (toilet leaks); US EPA WaterSense: Fix a Leak Week; Kohler: Toilet constantly leaking or running; Fluidmaster: How to identify and fix toilet flapper leaks.

How TalkFixAI talks you through a fix

The screens below illustrate a TalkFixAI conversation that follows the steps in this guide. Your own conversation will depend on what you describe.

  1. Illustrated TalkFixAI chat. You: “My toilet keeps running after I flush.” TalkFixAI: “Lift the tank lid and lay it on a towel. Is water spilling into the open tube in the middle?”
    Step 1Toilet keeps running?Lift the lid and watch.
  2. Illustrated TalkFixAI chat. You: “Yes, it's flowing into the tube.” TalkFixAI: “The water level is too high. Turn the fill valve's adjustment screw or slide its float down a little.”
    Step 2Small parts, quick fix.Chain, water level, fill valve.
  3. Illustrated TalkFixAI chat. You: “It still refills on its own sometimes.” TalkFixAI: “Add a few drops of food colouring to the tank and wait 10 minutes without flushing.”
    Step 3Silent leak? Test it.A few drops of food colouring.

Want TalkFixAI to talk you through this repair hands-free while your hands are busy? Try TalkFixAI, the free repair assistant that answers by voice, even offline.

Other plumbing fixes